As you can see, the question above is not, “Should you add chocolate to your cookies?” That’s because that shouldn’t even be a question. Chocolate belongs in cookies, just like milk belongs in cereal. How do you choose the best chocolate for the job? Below, a few of our readers share tips on just how to do that.
Chareena Pamittan

Chareena Pamittan

Resident Nutritionist-Dietitian of FoodzThesis.

Choose A Dark Chocolate Bar

I highly suggest choosing dark chocolate, as its bitterness creates a flavourful balance to the dough’s sweetness. Choose a chocolate that has 50% to 90% of chocolate solids.

Always opt for dark chocolate bars instead of dark chocolate chips because the bars have a higher cocoa butter percentage. Hence, when baked, they still retain the velvety and soft texture. The cookies also have a unique texture that chocolate chips cannot give.

Consider Who The Cookies Are For

Here are a few things to consider when choosing the right chocolate for your cookies:

    ● Identify Your Consumer: Most kids will love milk and white chocolate instead of dark chocolate in their cookies. Adults are more into less sweet [cookies], so it’s a choice between semi-sweet and dark chocolate. Semi-sweet chocolates add the perfect balance of sweetness and chocolate flavor.

    ● Desired Texture: If you want a soft, chewy, gooey, melt-in-your-mouth cookie, then couverture chocolate is perfect. This chocolate readily melts while baking. But compound chocolate will work best for you if you prefer a crispy cookie with bits or chunks of chocolate. They hold their shape well and will soften a bit but will not melt easily.

    ● Preferred Flavor: Milk chocolates have a sweet, creamy flavor and contain 10-50% cocoa solids, while dark chocolates are less sweet, with a hint of bitterness and a more intense chocolate note, thanks to their high cocoa solid content (50-90%). Remember that the higher the percentage of cocoa solids, the less sweet and more bitter it will be.

    ● Food Combination: Some foods blend well with others. Nuts in cookies usually complement almost all kinds of chocolates. For cookie-containing fruits, I love using dark chocolates to balance the fruit’s sweetness and tanginess. On the other hand, for matcha cookies, I prefer using white chocolates to mellow down the flavor.

    ● Nutritional Profile: Health-wise, dark chocolates are the best option. They are rich in flavanols, a plant chemical that may help protect the heart. Flavanols also lower blood pressure by supporting the production of nitric oxide, which helps relax the blood vessels and improve blood flow. Choose at least 70% dark chocolate for the most amount of flavanols.

    Dark chocolate is calorie-dense and contains moderate amounts of unsaturated fats. Consuming the proper quantity will ensure considerable health benefits.

Blanca Garcia

Blanca Garcia

Registered Dietitian Nutritionist and a nutrition specialist at .
Annie V. Rolen

Annie V. Rolen

Choose A High-Quality Chocolate That Will Compliment The Cookie

Here are some tips for choosing the best chocolate for your cookies:

    1. Look For High-Quality Chocolate:
    Choose chocolate from high-quality ingredients, such as cocoa butter and real vanilla. High-quality chocolate will have a smoother texture and a more complex flavor.

    2. Consider The Cacao Percentage:
    The higher the cacao percentage, the darker and more intense the chocolate flavor. If you prefer a stronger chocolate flavor in your cookies, look for chocolate with a higher cacao percentage. On the other hand, if you prefer a milder chocolate flavor, opt for chocolate with a lower cacao percentage.

    3. Match The Chocolate To The Other Flavors In Your Cookies:
    Consider the other flavors in your cookies and choose a chocolate that complements them. For example, if you’re making peanut butter cookies, choose chocolate with a lower cacao percentage to avoid overpowering the peanut butter flavor.

    4. Consider The Form Of The Chocolate:
    Chocolate chips, chunks, and bars are all options for adding chocolate to your cookies. Chocolate chips are convenient and easy to measure, but they may contain stabilizers that affect the texture of your cookies. Chunks and bars can be chopped into irregular pieces, creating chocolate pockets throughout your cookies.

    5. Experiment with different types of chocolate:
    There are many types of chocolate to choose from, including milk chocolate, dark chocolate, and white chocolate. Don’t be afraid to experiment with different types of chocolate to find your favorite flavor combination.

By following these tips, you can choose the best chocolate for your cookies and create a delicious and satisfying treat.

Consider The Desired End Result

Choosing the right type of chocolate for your cookies can make all the difference in flavor and texture. Here are some tips to help you choose the best chocolate for your cookies:

    1. Consider The Type Of Cookie
    The chocolate you choose should complement the cookie you make. For example, dark chocolate pairs well with oatmeal cookies, while milk chocolate is great for chocolate chip cookies.

    2. Choose High-Quality Chocolate
    The quality of the chocolate you use can significantly impact the taste of your cookies. Look for chocolate made with high-quality ingredients and a high percentage of cocoa solids.

    3. Pay Attention To The Cocoa Percentage
    The percentage of cocoa in the chocolate will determine its flavor and sweetness. Choose chocolate with more cocoa solids for a more intense chocolate flavor. Choose chocolate with a lower percentage of cocoa solids for a sweeter taste.

    4. Choose The Right Format
    Chocolate chips are a popular choice for cookies, but you can also use chocolate chunks, chopped chocolate, or even grated chocolate. The format you choose will affect the texture of your cookies.

    5. Consider Any Dietary Restrictions
    Choose appropriate chocolate if you or your guests have dietary restrictions. For example, if you need to avoid dairy, look for vegan or dairy-free chocolate.

    6. Look For Chocolate In Bars Or Chunks
    Instead of chocolate chips, consider chopped chocolate bars or chunks. This will give your cookies a more rustic and homemade look.

    7. Choose The Right Size
    Consider the size of your chocolate pieces. Smaller pieces will melt more quickly and create a more uniform texture, while larger pieces will create pockets of melted chocolate throughout the cookie.

    8. Experiment With Flavors
    Add an extra dimension of flavor to your cookies using flavored chocolate, such as mint, orange, or raspberry.

    9. Consider Your Audience
    If you are making cookies for children, consider using milk or white chocolate, which are generally milder and sweeter than dark chocolate.

    10. Taste Test
    Taste different types of chocolate before making your final decision. This will help you choose the chocolate you like best and [that will] work well in your cookies.

Following these tips, you can choose the best chocolate for your cookies and create delicious treats everyone will love.

Ethelyn Dietrich

Professional Chef at .

This is a crowdsourced article. Contributors' statements do not necessarily reflect the opinion of this website, other people, businesses, or other contributors.